CLASS I Food recall · Reported 12 May 2021 · FDA Enforcement Report

Super Dip Cookies n Cream Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalled

Velvet Ice Cream is recalling Super Dip Cookies n Cream Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail, distributed in 9 states. The recall was initiated on 23 Apr 2021 and the FDA has classified it as Class I.

Check your package

Lot, batch or date codesLot 21083
Quantity recalledN/A

Do not eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away. If you have symptoms after eating it, contact a doctor.

Recall details

Recall number
F-0593-2021
FDA event ID
87796
Recalling firm
Velvet Ice Cream, Utica, OH
Brand
Super
Classification
Class I
Status
Terminated
Recall initiated
23 Apr 2021
FDA classified
22 May 2021
Reported
12 May 2021
Type
Voluntary: Firm initiated
Customers notified by
Telephone
Reason category
Listeria

Timeline

23 Apr 2021Recall initiated by company
12 May 2021Published in enforcement report+19 days
22 May 2021Classified by FDA+10 days

Companies usually start a recall weeks before the FDA classifies and publishes it; the gap above is that lag.

Reason for recall

Potentially contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes

Listeria monocytogenes can grow at refrigerator temperatures. Infection is most dangerous for pregnant women, newborns, older adults and people with weakened immune systems. Symptoms can appear up to 70 days after eating contaminated food.

Product as listed by the FDA

Super Dip Cookies n Cream Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail - 2 Gallons per case

Where it was distributed

Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, South Carolina, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, New York

IllinoisIndianaKentuckyMichiganNew YorkOhioPennsylvaniaSouth CarolinaWest Virginia

Questions about this recall

Why was it recalled?

Potentially contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes

Which lots are affected?

Lot 21083

Where was it sold?

Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, South Carolina, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, New York

What should I do if I have it?

Do not eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away. If you have symptoms after eating it, contact a doctor.

What does Class I mean?

Class I is the most serious FDA recall category: there is a reasonable probability that using the product will cause serious health consequences or death.

Read the official FDA notice · Source record retrieved 26 Sep 2026. The FDA describes openFDA data as unvalidated; the official notice takes precedence. This page reports the record and gives no medical advice.

Other products in this recall event

55 other products · FDA event 87796

This product is part of a recall event; the main page for the event is Velvet Cookies n Cream - 8 cartons to a case Tub - 1 Tub recalled.

ReportedClassRecallCompanyReasonWhere
CLASS IVelvet Cookies n Cream - 8 cartons to a case Tub - 1 Tub recalledVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Vanilla Bean Tub - 1 Tub recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IWhale of Pail Vanilla Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamWhaleVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Vanilla Lovers Trio Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Mint Chocolate Chip Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalledVelvet MintVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Sea Salt Caramel Toffee Tub - 1 Tub recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet SeaVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Buckeye Brownie Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet BuckeyeVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Chocolate Pail Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalledSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Strawberry Ice Cream Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Vanilla Ice Cream Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Chocolate - 8 cartons to a pack recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IBuehler's Chocolate Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalledBuehler'sVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IWhale of Pail Neapolitan Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamWhaleVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Kentucky Praline Pecan Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet KentuckyVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Birthday Cake Tub - 1 Tub recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet BirthdayVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IRuggle's Orange Sherbet Quart recalled by Velvet Ice CreamRuggle'sVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Blackberry Cheesecake Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet BlackberryVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Pineapple Sherbet in a case Tub - 1 Tub recalledVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Chocolate Swirl Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalledSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Vanilla - 8 cartons to a case recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Raspberry Sherbet in a Pack recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Black Walnut Tub - 1 Tub recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IDiscount Drug Mart Strawberry Ice Cream Carton recalledDiscount DrugVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Butter Pecan & Cashew - 8 cartons to a case recalledVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Blackberry Cobbler Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet BlackberryVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IDiscount Drug Mart Chocolate Swirl Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalledDiscount DrugVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Orange Sherbet in a case Tub - 1 Tub in a case recalledVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Banana Cream Pie Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Superfriends Ice Cream Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Elephant Ear Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet ElephantVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Cookie Dough Extreme Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalledVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IBuehler's Vanilla Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalledBuehler'sVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IDiscount Drug Mart Vanilla Ice Cream - 4 Cartons Gallon Plastic Pail recalledDiscount DrugVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Olde Tyme Vanilla Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet OldeVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Original Vanilla Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Moose Tracks - 8 cartons to a case - 4 cartons to a case recalledVelvet MooseVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Summertime Peach Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet SummertimeVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Dutch Chocolate Tub - 1 Tub Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet DutchVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IWhale of Pail Chocolate Fudge Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamWhaleVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS INorth Star Frog Spit 6 pops recalled by Velvet Ice CreamNorth StarVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Rainbow Sherbet in a case Tub - 1 Tub in a case recalledVelvet RainbowVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IBuehler's Neapolitan Ice Cream Gallon Plastic Pail recalledBuehler's NeapolitanVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Lime Sherbet in a case recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Caramel Pecan Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet CaramelVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Triple Chocolate Chunk Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet TripleVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Campfire Smores Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet CampfireVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IWhale of Pail Cookies n Cream Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamWhaleVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Homemade Vanilla Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvetVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Buckeye Classic - 8 cartons to a case - 4 cartons to a case recalledVelvet BuckeyeVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IWhale of Pail Vanilla Chocolate Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamWhaleVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IDiscount Drug Mart Neapolitan Ice Cream Carton recalledDiscount DrugVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IBuckeye Sandwich per box recalled by Velvet Ice CreamBuckeyeVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS IVelvet Cotton Candy Tub - 1 Tub recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet CottonVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Vanilla/Orange Ice Cream Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
CLASS ISuper Dip Neapolitan Pail Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states

More recalls from Velvet Ice Cream

All 59
ReportedClassRecallCompanyReasonWhere
FoodCLASS IRaspberry Fudge Cordial recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet Ice CreamUndeclared Allergens5 states
FoodCLASS ISuper Dip Neapolitan Pail Gallon recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
FoodCLASS ISuper Dip Vanilla/Orange Ice Cream Carton recalled by Velvet Ice CreamSuperVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
FoodCLASS IVelvet Cotton Candy Tub - 1 Tub recalled by Velvet Ice CreamVelvet CottonVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states
FoodCLASS IBuckeye Sandwich per box recalled by Velvet Ice CreamBuckeyeVelvet Ice CreamListeria9 states

Other Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts recalls

All 1,761
ReportedClassRecallCompanyReasonWhere
FoodANNOUNCEDSo Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster Non-Dairy recalledSo Delicious Dairy FreeDanone USAForeign Material
FoodCLASS IIOutshine Fruit Bars Tangerine recalled by Dreyer's Grand Ice CreamOutshineDreyer's Grand Ice CreamForeign Material33 states
FoodCLASS IIOutshine Fruit Bars Strawberry, Pineapple, Grape, Tangerine recalledOutshineDreyer's Grand Ice CreamForeign Material33 states
FoodCLASS IIOutshine Fruit Bars Black Cherry recalled by Dreyer's Grand Ice CreamOutshineDreyer's Grand Ice CreamForeign Material33 states
FoodCLASS IIOutshine Fruit Bars Strawberry recalled by Dreyer's Grand Ice CreamOutshineDreyer's Grand Ice CreamForeign Material33 states