CLASS II Food recall · Reported 29 Nov 2023 · FDA Enforcement Report

Buttercream Birthday Cake Ice Cream recalled

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is recalling Buttercream Birthday Cake Ice Cream. The recall was initiated on 9 Nov 2023 and the FDA has classified it as Class II.

Check your package

Lot, batch or date codesBatch/Lot Numbers: 23-004, 23-087, 23-088, 23-118, 23-215 Product Numbers: 5015b (case), 1064b (pint) Manufacturer Number: 26-012

Quantity recalled58,473.88 cases

Do not eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away. If you have symptoms after eating it, contact a doctor.

Recall details

Recall number: F-0465-2024
FDA event ID: 93402
Recalling firm: Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams, Columbus, OH
Brand: Jeni's Splendid
Classification: Class II
Status: Terminated
Recall initiated: 9 Nov 2023
FDA classified: 21 Nov 2023
Reported: 29 Nov 2023
Type: Voluntary: Firm initiated
Customers notified by: E-Mail
Reason category: Foreign Material
Product category: Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts

Timeline

9 Nov 2023	Recall initiated by company
21 Nov 2023	Classified by FDA	+12 days
29 Nov 2023	Published in enforcement report	+8 days

Companies usually start a recall weeks before the FDA classifies and publishes it; the gap above is that lag.

Reason for recall

Potential Foreign Material - aluminum and/or stainless steel pieces

Foreign material recalls cover pieces of metal, plastic, glass, wood or other objects that got into the product during processing and could cause injury if eaten.

Product as listed by the FDA

Jeni's Splendid Ice Cream: Buttercream Birthday Cake Ice Cream packaged in paperboard pint cups with heat seals and paper lids - 8 pints per case

Where it was distributed

All US states

Questions about this recall

Why was it recalled?

Potential Foreign Material - aluminum and/or stainless steel pieces

Which lots are affected?

Batch/Lot Numbers: 23-004, 23-087, 23-088, 23-118, 23-215 Product Numbers: 5015b (case), 1064b (pint) Manufacturer Number: 26-012

Where was it sold?

All US states

What should I do if I have it?

Do not eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away. If you have symptoms after eating it, contact a doctor.

What does Class II mean?

Class II means the product may cause temporary or medically reversible health problems, or the probability of serious harm is remote.

Read the official FDA notice · Source record retrieved 26 Sep 2026. The FDA describes openFDA data as unvalidated; the official notice takes precedence. This page reports the record and gives no medical advice.

More recalls from Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

All 169

Reported	Class	Recall	Company	Reason	Where
3 Dec 2025Food	CLASS II	Jeni's Passion Fruit Dreamsicle Ice Cream Bars recalledJeni's Passion	Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams	Undeclared Allergens	10 states
5 Feb 2020Food	CLASS I	Jeni's Dairy Free Cold Brew with Coconut Cream Pints frozen dessert recalledJeni's	Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams	Undeclared Milk	50 states
16 Sep 2015Food	CLASS I	Loveless Biscuits + Peach Jam Ice Cream Bucket recalledLoveless Biscuits	Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams	Listeria	Nationwide
16 Sep 2015Food	CLASS I	Spiced Purple Yam Bucket, 329, Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams recalledSpiced Purple	Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams	Listeria	Nationwide
16 Sep 2015Food	CLASS I	Cherry Lambic Ice Cream Bucket recalled by Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams	Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams	Listeria	Nationwide

Other Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts recalls

All 1,764

Reported	Class	Recall	Company	Reason	Where
17 Oct 2026Food	ANNOUNCED	Gelatelli Coffee & Vanilla Gelato with Coffee Sauce & Cookie Pieces recalledGelatelli	Lidl US	Listeria	10 states
2 Oct 2026Food	ANNOUNCED	Ice cream recalled by Stewart’s ShopStewart’s Shops	Stewart’s Shop	Foreign Material	NH, NY, VT
30 Sep 2026Food	CLASS II	So Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster Cashewmilk recalledSo Delicious	WWF Operating	Foreign Material	Nationwide
15 Sep 2026Food	ANNOUNCED	So Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster Non-Dairy recalledSo Delicious Dairy Free	Danone USA	Foreign Material
2 Sep 2026Food	CLASS II	Outshine Fruit Bars Tangerine recalled by Dreyer's Grand Ice CreamOutshine	Dreyer's Grand Ice Cream	Foreign Material	33 states