CLASS II Food recall · Reported 5 Sep 2012 · FDA Enforcement Report

Cass Clay, New York Cherry Ice Cream recalled

Cass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo Division is recalling Cass Clay, New York Cherry Ice Cream, distributed in Arizona, Kansas, Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota. The recall was initiated on 20 Jul 2012 and the FDA has classified it as Class II.

Check your package

Lot, batch or date codesall products that has a plant code of "38-25".
Quantity recalled119 containers

Do not eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away. If you have symptoms after eating it, contact a doctor.

Recall details

Recall number
F-2043-2012
FDA event ID
62644
Classification
Class II
Status
Terminated
Recall initiated
20 Jul 2012
FDA classified
24 Aug 2012
Reported
5 Sep 2012
Type
Voluntary: Firm initiated
Customers notified by
Two or more of the following: Email, Fax, Letter, Press Release, Telephone, Visit
Reason category
Undeclared Allergens

Timeline

20 Jul 2012Recall initiated by company
24 Aug 2012Classified by FDA+35 days
5 Sep 2012Published in enforcement report+12 days

Companies usually start a recall weeks before the FDA classifies and publishes it; the gap above is that lag.

Reason for recall

Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared yellow #5.

Food allergen labelling is required by US law for the nine major allergens. A product recalled for an undeclared allergen is only a risk to people with that allergy; everyone else can consume it safely.

Product as listed by the FDA

CASS CLAY, NEW YORK CHERRY ICE CREAM, 3 GALLON (11.34 L).

Where it was distributed

ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS

ArizonaKansasMinnesotaNorth DakotaSouth Dakota

Questions about this recall

Why was it recalled?

Cass-Clay Creamery is voluntarily recalling a number of ice cream products because they may contain undeclared yellow #5.

Which lots are affected?

all products that has a plant code of "38-25".

Where was it sold?

ND, AZ, MN, SD, KS

What should I do if I have it?

Do not eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away. If you have symptoms after eating it, contact a doctor.

What does Class II mean?

Class II means the product may cause temporary or medically reversible health problems, or the probability of serious harm is remote.

Read the official FDA notice · Source record retrieved 26 Sep 2026. The FDA describes openFDA data as unvalidated; the official notice takes precedence. This page reports the record and gives no medical advice.

Other products in this recall event

28 other products · FDA event 62644

This product is part of a recall event; the main page for the event is Dan's, Light Butter Pecan, half gallon * recalled.

ReportedClassRecallCompanyReasonWhere
CLASS IIDan's, Light Butter Pecan, half gallon * recalledDan'sCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Duluth Dark Chocolate recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Tin Roof Sundae Cass Clay, Tin Roof Sundae recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IIHornbachers, Light French Vanilla, Half Gallon recalledHornbachersCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IIHornbachers, French Vanilla Ice Cream, Half-gallon recalledHornbachersCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IICass-clay: Light Dusty Road, 0 70422 23480 Light Ice Cream recalledCass-clayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Wheat & Gluten5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Winter Wonder, half gallon recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass-Clay, Cookies 'N Vanilla recalledCass-ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass-Clay , Swiss Chip recalledCass-ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Peppermint Candy, half gallon recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass Clay Chocolate Monster recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IISchroeder, Ice Cream, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough recalledSchroederCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Wheat & Gluten5 states
CLASS IICass-clay, Double Chocolate Fudge, Premium Light Ice Cream recalledCass-clayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Peanuts5 states
CLASS IICass-Clay, Und Champion Chip recalledCass-ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Cookies 'N Cream (, 0 70422 45034 9 Cass Clay recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass-Clay, Strawberry Cheesecake recalledCass-ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IICass-Clay, Butter Pecan recalledCass-ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IISunnyBrook, Chocolate Chip recalled by Cass Clay Creamery AMPI FargoSunnyBrookCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IICass-clay, Praline Pecan recalledCass-clayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IISunnybrook, Light Cookies 'N Cream, half gallon, 0 recalledSunnybrookCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS ICass-clay, Ice Cream, Artificially Flavored Maple Nut recalledCass-clayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IIICass-clay, Bubble Gum recalledCass-clayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS ICass-clay, Ice cream, Light Maple Nut, 0 recalledCass-clayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IIHornbachers, Peanut Butter Fudge, Half Gallon, 0 recalledHornbachersCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Peanuts5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Bison Crunch, half gallon 0 70422 04033 5 Cass recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Light Candy Bar, half gallon ) 0 recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Light Brownie Fdg, ( 0 70422 23485 7 Cass Clay recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
CLASS IICass Clay, Light Muddy Sneakers, half gallon 0 recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states

More recalls from Cass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo Division

All 30
ReportedClassRecallCompanyReasonWhere
FoodCLASS IICass Clay, Light Muddy Sneakers, half gallon 0 recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
FoodCLASS IICass Clay, Light Brownie Fdg, ( 0 70422 23485 7 Cass Clay recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
FoodCLASS IICass Clay, Light Candy Bar, half gallon ) 0 recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Allergens5 states
FoodCLASS IICass Clay, Bison Crunch, half gallon 0 70422 04033 5 Cass recalledCass ClayCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Soy5 states
FoodCLASS IIHornbachers, Peanut Butter Fudge, Half Gallon, 0 recalledHornbachersCass Clay Creamery Ampi Fargo DivisionUndeclared Peanuts5 states

Other Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts recalls

All 1,763
ReportedClassRecallCompanyReasonWhere
FoodANNOUNCEDIce cream recalled by Stewart’s ShopStewart’s ShopsStewart’s ShopForeign MaterialNH, NY, VT
FoodCLASS IISo Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster Cashewmilk recalledSo DeliciousWWF OperatingForeign MaterialNationwide
FoodANNOUNCEDSo Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster Non-Dairy recalledSo Delicious Dairy FreeDanone USAForeign Material
FoodCLASS IIOutshine Fruit Bars Tangerine recalled by Dreyer's Grand Ice CreamOutshineDreyer's Grand Ice CreamForeign Material33 states
FoodCLASS IIOutshine Fruit Bars Strawberry, Pineapple, Grape, Tangerine recalledOutshineDreyer's Grand Ice CreamForeign Material33 states