Creamy recalls

Creamy products have been recalled 22 times, most recently on 18 Feb 2026. The recalling company is usually Helados La Tapatia. The most common reason is undeclared egg.

Total recalls22since 2012

Last 12 months3reported

Class I1882% of total

Ongoing0latest 18 Feb 2026

Recalls per month, last 24 months

click a bar for that month

0Nov '24 0 0 0Feb 0 0 0May 1 0 0Aug 0 0 0Nov 0 0 3Feb 0 0 0May 0 0 0Aug 0 0

Severity split

Class I 18 82%Class II 4 18%Class III 0 0%

Why creamy is recalled

Companies

Product types

By year

2026314%
202515%
201915%
20161150%
2012627%

All creamy recalls, newest first

22 total

Reported	Class	Recall	Company	Reason	Where
18 Feb 2026Food	CLASS II	Creamy Peanut Butter recalled by Ventura FoodsCreamy	Ventura Foods	Foreign Material	40 states
18 Feb 2026Food	CLASS II	Creamy Peanut Butter recalled by Ventura FoodsCreamy	Ventura Foods	Foreign Material	40 states
18 Feb 2026Food	CLASS II	Creamy Peanut Butter recalled by Ventura FoodsCreamy	Ventura Foods	Foreign Material	40 states
25 Jun 2025Food	CLASS II	Creamy Avocado Spicy Refrigerated recalled by Pain Train SalsaCreamy	Pain Train Salsa	Undeclared Milk	TX
20 Feb 2019Food	CLASS I	Creamy Cashew Butter recalled by Thrive MarketCreamy	Thrive Market	Listeria	Nationwide
26 Oct 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Almond Butter recalled by New Seasons MarketCreamy	NEW Seasons Market	Labeling Errors	CA, OR, WA
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
6 Jan 2016Food	CLASS I	Creamy Fruit Bars recalled by Helados La TapatiaCreamy	Helados La Tapatia	Undeclared Egg	4 states
31 Oct 2012Food	CLASS I	Creamy Butter recalled by Sunland, IncorporatedCreamy	Sunland	Salmonella	Nationwide
31 Oct 2012Food	CLASS I	Creamy Sugar Butter recalled by Sunland, IncorporatedCreamy	Sunland	Salmonella	Nationwide
31 Oct 2012Food	CLASS I	Creamy Almond Butter recalled by Sunland, IncorporatedCreamy	Sunland	Salmonella	Nationwide
31 Oct 2012Food	CLASS I	Creamy Dark Roast Peanut Butter recalled by Sunland, IncorporatedCreamy	Sunland	Salmonella	Nationwide
31 Oct 2012Food	CLASS I	Creamy Peanut Butter recalled by Sunland, IncorporatedCreamy	Sunland	Salmonella	Nationwide
31 Oct 2012Food	CLASS I	Creamy Peanut Butter with Sea Salt recalled by Sunland, IncorporatedCreamy	Sunland	Salmonella	Nationwide

About this list

Records come from FDA enforcement reports and USDA FSIS notices, grouped by normalised name. A company operating under several names may appear more than once.